Home » Book Reviews » Why India Needs the Presidential System – Bhanu Dhamija
Why India Needs the Presidential System - Bhanu Dhamija

Why India Needs the Presidential System – Bhanu Dhamija

Author: Bhanu Dhamija
Publisher: Harper Collins
Pages: 384
Price: Rs.550

Was “familiarity” the only reason why India adopted a parliamentary system of governance? In his book “Why India Needs the Presidential System”, author Bhanu Dhamija, himself a publisher, seeks to answer this question, while extending some radical thoughts on how we should be governed.

“The Indian system began to break down almost immediately after Independence, because the powers of its two topmost officials were poorly defined,” says Dhamija, 56, a non-resident Himachali, while calling for a federal set upnstead, given India’s diversity, size and communal divisions.

“The truth is the Indians adopted the British parliamentary system for poor and unsubstantiated reasons. Vallabbhai Patel, the first leader to attempt a justification of this system in India’s Constituent Assembly, could come up with only one reason: Familiarity.”

Dhamija, who is an alumunus of Punjab University in Chandigarh and the Stern School of Business, New York University, and has lived half his life in the US, says that the centralised, unitary control that the parliamentary system offers does not work for India.

According to him, the architect of the Constitution of India Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar alluded to two main benefits of the parliamentary system in the Constituent Assembly – one that it had the potential for a “more responsible” governments and the other of a “strong centre”.

He seeks to suggest how the benefits were not just unrealistic, but also impracticable. He also goes on to state that Jawaharlal Nehru, the first prime minister, almost single-handedly picked this system of government, but never really bothered to explain his choice in the assembly.

Check Also

Remembering Bollywood Legend Actor Balraj Sahni

Remembering Bollywood Legend Actor Balraj Sahni

This year marks the 103rd birth anniversary of the much-respected artist Balraj Sahni. It also …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *